Choosing the right wishlist app can help Shopify merchants improve the shopping experience, encourage repeat visits, and turn saved products into future purchases. A good wishlist solution allows customers to save their favourite products, organize their shopping preferences, and return whenever they are ready to buy.
Two options worth considering are Wishlist Guru: Favorites List and Wishlist – Wishify. Both apps help Shopify stores offer wishlist functionality, but they differ in features, customization options, integrations, and pricing.
In this comparison, we’ll explore Wishlist Guru vs Wishify, looking at their key features, pricing plans, and overall capabilities to help you choose the best Shopify wishlist app for your store.
Wishlist Guru Vs Wishlist – Wishify – In-Depth Shopify Wishlist App Comparison
This in-depth comparison of Wishlist Guru vs Wishlist – Wishify explores their features, pricing, customization options, integrations, and overall benefits. Discover how both Shopify wishlist apps help merchants improve customer engagement, encourage repeat visits, and make product saving easier, so you can choose the right solution for your store.
Wishlist Guru – Free Plan
Wishlist Guru offers a generous Free Plan with up to 300 wishlist items per month, along with essential tools to help Shopify merchants improve the shopping experience and encourage customers to save their favourite products.
Key Free Plan Features:
| Up to 300 wishlist items per month. | Easy one-click installation and setup. |
| Customizable wishlist buttons (icon, button, or text) | Wishlist display as a dedicated page or popup. |
| Heart icon or wishlist button on collection pages. | Guest wishlist functionality. |
| Language and translation customization. | Move wishlist products directly to cart. |
| Analytics, basic reports, and customer favourites reports. | Customizable notifications and floating/header icons. |
| Add wishlist widgets anywhere on the store. | Customize wishlist page content. |
| Share wishlists through URLs. | VIP support included. |
Wishlist ‑ Wishify – Free Plan
Wishify offers a basic Free Plan with up to 100 wishlist items per month and limited customization options to help merchants add essential wishlist functionality to their Shopify stores.
Key Free Plan Features:
| Up to 100 wishlist items per month. | Customize wishlist button colors and text. |
| Free app setup. | Add a wishlist page to the store’s main menu. |
| Custmer Support |
Wishlist Guru Vs Wishlist Wishify – Free Plan Summary
Both Wishlist Guru: Favorites List and Wishlist – Wishify offer free plans with essential wishlist functionality. However, Wishlist Guru provides greater value with a higher monthly wishlist limit and several additional features.
Wishlist Guru allows merchants to manage up to 300 wishlist items per month, compared to Wishify’s 100 items per month. Both apps offer wishlist button customization, free app setup, and a wishlist page in the main menu. However, Wishlist Guru goes further by including guest wishlist functionality, Move to Cart, language customization, collection page wishlist icons, wishlist sharing through URLs, floating and header icon customization, analytics, and customer favourite reports.
Overall, Wishlist Guru offers more features and three times the wishlist item allowance in its Free Plan, making it a more feature-rich option for Shopify merchants who want to offer customers a better wishlist experience without an upfront cost.
Wishlist Guru: Favorites List – Basic Plan ($5.99/month)
Wishlist Guru’s Basic Plan offers up to 2,000 wishlist items per month, along with advanced customization, reporting, and engagement tools to help Shopify merchants improve wishlist functionality and encourage customers to return to saved products.
Key Basic Plan Features:
| Up to 2,000 wishlist items per month. | Display wishlist in Drawer Mode. |
| Add wishlist buttons to the homepage, collection pages, and quick-view options. | Customize collection page wishlist icons (shape, size, position, and color). |
| Access detailed wishlist reports. | Custom JavaScript/CSS and code integration. |
| Social counters on product and collection pages. | Remove Wishlist Guru branding. |
| Monthly email reminders with customization options. | Custom JS actions after adding or removing wishlist items. |
| GDPR compliance features. | VIP support included. |
Wishlist ‑ Wishify – Professional Plan $5.99 / month
Wishify’s Professional Plan costs $5.99 per month and includes up to 1,000 wishlist items per month, along with additional wishlist customization and sharing features.
Key Professional Plan Features:
| Up to 1,000 wishlist items per month. | Share wishlists with others. |
| Wishlist widget on collection pages. | Guest wishlist functionality. |
| Export wishlist data. | Heart icon in the store header. |
| Customize app colors. |
Wishlist Guru Basic Plan Vs Wishlist ‑ Wishify – Professional Plan- Summary
When comparing the $5.99/month plans, Wishlist Guru clearly offers more features and greater value for Shopify merchants. While both apps provide wishlist functionality, their feature sets and monthly item limits are quite different. Wishlist Guru’s Basic Plan supports up to 2,000 wishlist items per month, whereas Wishify’s Professional Plan supports only 1,000 items at the same price.
Beyond the higher wishlist limit, Wishlist Guru includes several advanced features that Wishify does not offer in its Professional Plan, such as Drawer Mode, homepage and quick-view wishlist buttons, detailed analytics and reports, custom CSS/JS, custom code integration, social counters, branding removal, and customizable monthly email reminders. It also provides GDPR compliance features and VIP support. Wishify offers useful features like wishlist sharing, guest wishlists, data export, collection page widgets, and header icons, but its customization and reporting capabilities are comparatively limited.
Overall, Wishlist Guru’s Basic Plan delivers significantly more functionality at the same $5.99/month price, making it a stronger value-for-money choice for Shopify merchants who want advanced customization, higher wishlist capacity, detailed insights, and better customer engagement tools.
Wishlist Guru Pro Plan ($12.99/month) Vs Wishlist ‑ Wishify – Professional Plan $12.99 / month
Wishlist Guru Pro Plan
Wishlist Guru’s Pro Plan supports up to 5,000 wishlist items per month and introduces advanced features for customer engagement, multilingual communication, and B2B store management. It helps merchants recover potential sales through automated wishlist notifications and personalized email experiences.
Key Pro Plan Features:
| Up to 5,000 wishlist items per month. | Login-required wishlist functionality. |
| B2B support with hide/show price and Add to Cart controls on wishlist pages. | Support for 2 languages. |
| Automated price-drop, back-in-stock, and restock email alerts. | Allow customers to select their preferred email language. |
| Multilingual email templates. | Customizable email templates. |
| Up to 2,000 emails per month. | Enable or disable email notifications. |
| VIP support included. |
Wishlist ‑ Wishify – Professional Plan $12.99 / month
Wishify’s $12.99/month Professional Plan increases the monthly wishlist allowance to 3,000 items and includes all features from its previous Professional Plan, along with full reporting capabilities.
Key Professional Plan Features:
| Up to 3,000 wishlist items per month. | All features included in the previous Professional Plan. |
| Full wishlist reports and analytics. |
Wishlist Guru Pro Plan Vs Wishlist ‑ Wishify – Professional Plan – Summary
Wishlist Guru‘s Pro Plan offers more value compared to Wishify’s Professional Plan, particularly for merchants looking for advanced wishlist functionality. While Wishify provides up to 3,000 wishlist items per month and full reports, Wishlist Guru increases the allowance to 5,000 wishlist items per month, giving merchants greater capacity at the same price.
In addition to the higher wishlist limit, Wishlist Guru includes several advanced features that Wishify does not list in its Professional Plan, such as login-required wishlists, B2B-specific hide/show price and Add to Cart controls, multilingual support for two languages, automated price-drop and back-in-stock email alerts, customizable multilingual email templates, and up to 2,000 monthly notification emails. Customers can also select their preferred email language, while merchants can enable or disable notifications according to their requirements. VIP support is included as well.
Although Wishify offers full wishlist reports, Wishlist Guru provides a broader range of features focused on B2B functionality, multilingual experiences, and automated customer engagement.
Overall, Wishlist Guru‘s Pro Plan offers 5,000 wishlist items and a more extensive set of advanced features at the same price, making it a stronger value-for-money option for Shopify merchants.
Wishlist Guru Premium Plan ($19.99/month) Vs Wishlist ‑ Wishify – Advanced Plan $29.99 / month
Wishlist Guru Premium Plan
Wishlist Guru’s $19.99/month Premium Plan offers unlimited wishlist items and advanced customization options, along with powerful integrations, multilingual capabilities, detailed reporting, and automation features to help Shopify merchants deliver a seamless wishlist experience.
Key Features Included:
| Unlimited Wishlist Items | Unlimited Multi-Language Support |
| Unlimited Multilingual Email Templates | Domain-Based Language Settings |
| Multiple Wishlists | Multi-Variant Support |
| Save for Later | Klaviyo Integration |
| Email Reports | Social Media Wishlist Sharing |
| Wishlist Sharing Permissions (Logged-in Users & Guests) | Wishlist Sharing Reports |
| Customizable Wishlist Sharing Templates | SMTP Integration |
| Product Options App Support | Wishlist-to-Quote Integration |
| Up to 5,000 Emails per Month | Shopify Flow Integration |
| REST API Support | JavaScript Events Support |
| Affiliate Tracking via Customer Metafields | EU Privacy & GDPR Compliance |
Wishlist ‑ Wishify – Advanced Plan
Wishify’s Advanced Plan increases the monthly wishlist allowance to 10,000 items and includes automatic wishlist reminder emails to help merchants re-engage customers and encourage repeat purchases. It also includes all features from the Professional Plan.
Key Features Included:
| Up to 10,000 Wishlist Items per Month | Automatic Wishlist Reminder Emails |
| All Features of the Professional Plan |
Wishlist Guru Premium Plan Vs Wishlist ‑ Wishify – Advanced Plan – Summary
The biggest difference between the two plans is pricing and the range of features offered. Wishify’s Advanced Plan costs $29.99/month, whereas Wishlist Guru’s Premium Plan is available for just $19.99/month, saving merchants approximately $10 per month.
While Wishify offers up to 10,000 wishlist items per month and automatic wishlist reminder emails, Wishlist Guru provides unlimited wishlist items and includes automatic wishlist reminders in its Basic Plan.
Additionally, Wishlist Guru offers several advanced features and integrations, including unlimited multilingual email templates, domain-based language settings, multiple wishlists, unlimited wishlists, multi-variant support, Save for Later, Klaviyo integration, Wishlist-to-Quote integration, SMTP, Shopify Flow, REST API, JavaScript events, affiliate tracking, and advanced wishlist sharing and reporting capabilities.
Overall, Wishlist Guru Premium offers more features at a lower monthly price, making it a more cost-effective and feature-rich choice for Shopify merchants looking for an advanced wishlist solution. With its unlimited wishlist capacity, extensive integrations, multilingual capabilities, and advanced customization options, Wishlist Guru stands out as one of the best wishlist apps available in the Shopify App Store, offering excellent value for money.
Final Verdict: Which Wishlist App Should You Choose?
Both Wishlist Guru and Wishify offer useful wishlist features, but Wishlist Guru stands out with its higher wishlist limits, advanced functionality, and competitive pricing. Across its plans, Wishlist Guru provides more features at the same price, including advanced customization, detailed reporting, automated email reminders, multilingual support, and powerful integrations.
The biggest advantage comes with the Premium Plan. At just $19.99/month, Wishlist Guru offers unlimited wishlist items and integrations such as Klaviyo, Shopify Flow, REST API, and SMTP. Wishify’s Advanced Plan costs $29.99/month, making Wishlist Guru approximately $10/month(120/year) more affordable.
Overall, Wishlist Guru offers an excellent combination of affordability, advanced features, and scalability. Whether you run a small Shopify store or a growing business, it is a cost-effective, feature-rich solution and deserves consideration as one of the best wishlist apps in the Shopify App Store.



